Implementing flow control in centrifugal pumps and fans by means of variable speed AC drive instead of the traditional mechanical flow control devices is capable of providing energy savings from 10% to 60% depending on the application. This typically provides a return on investment (ROI) of 6 to 24 months, depending on the process load and if this is a new design or a retrofitting of existing installation.
VFD Application for Energy Saving in Pumps and Fans
Above mentioned ROI, is not considering the other economic benefits of using variable speed AC drives, such as:
- Reduced maintenance costs,
- reduced process variability,
- improved plant overall power factor,
- and elimination of valves as sources of fugitive emissions.
The Energy Crises
Egypt is experiencing one of its most series energy crises for decades, the rising population and the intense heat waves lead to electricity demand around 20% more than the available generation capacity. This is calling for innovative -industry proven- solutions to enhance energy efficiency that would lead to reduction of the overall demand as well as reduction of CO2 emissions and carbon foot-print.
This paper discusses the use of variable speed AC drives with pumps and fans for flow control applications instead of a control valve or louver, and how this can help in achieving high levels of energy savings, increase equipment life-time and allow for safer and more environment friendly operation.
Traditional Flow Control Approach
Controlling the flow of centrifugal pumps and fans is traditionally achieved by means of mechanical flow control devices (i.e. control valves and louvers). Although such technique has been the standard of all process control text books over the years, they fail short in providing any significant reduction in energy consumption in response to a reduced process demand, figure 1 illustrates the relation between power consumption against a varying flow rate by means of a control valve.
Figure 1 – Flow/Power profile for valve control
As illustrated in figure 1, reducing the flow by 20% by means of control valves or louvers will have minimal or no impact on the rotating equipment energy consumption. This lack of direct relation between product flow rate and its energy consumption contributes directly to the increase of per-unit production cost, and the increase of plant’s carbon foot-print.
Another drawback for the use of such traditional method of flow control is an increase of operating pressure of the rotating equipment, which is a major contributor to frequent leaks, increased vibration and motors overheating. Figure 2 explains the relation between valve control and operating pressure.
Figure 2 – Pump/System curve operating point change with throttling valve
The above mentioned factors have a direct impact in increasing the plant operation and maintenance costs as well as increasing the unplanned maintenance activities.
Variable Frequency Drives, the Smart Solution
Variable frequency drives (VFD) are becoming more common place and more widely used in applications. They are capable of varying the output speed of a motor without the need for mechanical pulleys, thus reducing the number of mechanical components and overall maintenance. But the biggest advantage that a VFD has is the ability to save the user money through its inheriting nature to save energy by consuming only the power that’s needed.
A VFD is similar to the motor to which it’s attached, they both convert power to a usable form. In the case of an induction motor, the electrical power supplied to it is converted to mechanical power through the rotation of the motor’s rotor and the torque that it produces through motor slip. A VFD, on the other hand, will convert its incoming power, a fixed voltage and frequency, to a variable voltage and frequency. This same concept is also the basis to vary the speed of the motor without the need of adjustable pulleys or gearing changes.
Figure 3 – Variable Frequency Drive vs Throttling Control Valve
Energy savings by using a VFD is derived from the laws of Affinity that states:
- Flow is proportional to shaft speed
- Head (pressure) is proportional to the square of shaft speed
- Power is proportional to the cube of shaft speed
Figure 4 – Affinity Low Curves
Applying the affinity low to the power consumption curve of centrifugal pump or fan shows the amount of energy that can be saved at the same operating point of the throttling valve approach; figure 5 shows energy saving of almost 50% in response to a 20% reduction in flow rate.
Figure 5 – VFD flow control vs. Throttling valve flow control
When looking at the VFD control from the pump/system curves point of view, it shows the additional benefits of reduced operating pressure at the same flow rates, and thus reduced vibrations, leakage potential and mechanical failures.
Figure 6 – Pump/system curve operating point change with speed control
VFD Flow Control Limitation and Solution
The main limitation in flow control using VFD/pump combination is presented in processes where very wide range of flow rates is required to be achievable, for example a range from 20% to 100% of nominal flow rate. Operating the pump at very low speeds will result in very low produced pump head, this head may not be enough to overcome the static system head, and so flow may never build-up.
Figure 7 – VFD flow control at minimum operating point
The solution for the above limitation, a combination of VFD and a control valve can be utilized, with a split range control algorithm, so the VFD regulates the high flow rates down to a certain minimum, and when the process demands lower flow-rates, the control valve starts adjusting the system curve to achieve the requested lower flow rate.
Figure 8 – Combined VFD & Control valve action
VFD Flow Control Economic Benefits
Dramatic energy cost reduction obtained by elimination of the pressure drop across the pump
If the energy savings were small, then this would be an irrelevant point. However, there are so many liquid flow pumps in processes that pump up to a high head, only to take that energy loss as pressure drop across a control valve, that this source of energy loss may be as much as 60% of the pump energy and up to 25% of the total energy used to operate a refinery, paper mill or chemical plant. Then too, if we designed our processes from the beginning with the VFD/pump, we could use much smaller electric drive motors.
Better control leading to reduced process variability and increased in-spec product
It is well known that the most often cited problem in tuning of PID control loops is the variable hysteresis introduced into the flow loop by control valve stickiness. The control valve also introduces a lag due to mechanical motion of the valve actuator itself. Control loops that have been optimally tuned at plant startup must gradually be detuned as the stickiness of the control valve builds, or the loop may become unstable. Today, we seem to accept this kind of sub-optimal process performance, but we can do better by replacement of the major source of error—the control valve—with a VFD/pump.
Reduced overall plant maintenance cost
From one hand, removing “or neutralizing” the control valve, which is a component with a high demand on maintenance resources is a great source of cost reduction. On the other hand, operating the pumps at lower pressure levels increases the life time of the pump itself, reducing stresses and vibrations on all mechanical components of the system and reduces possibilities of leakage as well.
Eliminating of a source of fugitive emissions
The benefit obtained from the elimination of fugitive emissions known to originate at the packing of the control valve stem is obvious when the control valve is eliminated.
Improvement in plant power factor
A less obvious benefit of using a VFD rather than discrete motor starters is operation at a near-unity power factor. Many plants use expensive capacitor banks to enhance their overall power factor, these capacitor banks also require regular maintenance and replacement. Thus, the use of VFDs eliminates the need of most of plant’s capacitor banks.
Conclusion, VFD is Better than FCV
It seems clear that using a VFD/pump combination to replace the use of an AC line-powered electric motor and a control valve is a superior way to do flow control and reap large benefits in lower energy consumption with better energy efficiency. There is also the potential for improved process control from elimination of the problems of control valves.
June 30, 2015 at 12:24 pm
Good. I have experience this 15 years back. Many type VLT I used for centrfigual pumps and flow controls. Thanks to remind me all this
LikeLike
June 30, 2015 at 7:16 pm
You are most welcome, the purpose of this blog is to create enriching automation and control discussions that is related to industry applications. It’s my pleasure to have to with us..
LikeLike
June 30, 2015 at 12:28 pm
Please update any thing new
LikeLike
June 30, 2015 at 7:23 pm
In the home page, drop your email address and click “Follow”, this way you will receive an email each time I post something on the blog.
Also you can LIKE “The Control Blog” page on Facebook, you can do that by clicking LIKE on the top right corner of this webpage. Each time a blog post is posted here it is automatically posted on our Facebook page as well.
LikeLike
July 1, 2015 at 3:20 pm
buen dia shady gracias por compartir tus pequeñas gotas de saber continua con esa aptitud.
Translated to English:
“good day shady thanks for sharing your knowledge droplets continue with that ability.”
LikeLike
July 1, 2015 at 4:10 pm
You are most welcome, Fredys.
Make sure you sign up for email updates, another article coming soon.
Good day to you too 🙂
LikeLike
July 3, 2015 at 8:10 pm
Thanks for the well structured information. I’ll refer my clients to read this.
LikeLike
July 3, 2015 at 9:40 pm
You and your clients are most welcomed.. Don’t forget to click the Follow botton to receive email notifications of new posts.. Also you can like The Control Blog page on facebook.
LikeLike
July 13, 2015 at 8:02 am
Supper sir
LikeLike
July 13, 2015 at 8:37 am
Thank you!
LikeLike
August 6, 2015 at 8:19 pm
Excellent blog here! Also your website quite
a bit up very fast! What host are you the usage
of? Can I get your affiliate hyperlink for your host?
I wish my site loaded up as quickly as yours lol
LikeLike
August 6, 2015 at 8:41 pm
This blog is hosted with wordpress.com
LikeLike
September 26, 2015 at 7:08 am
This is very attention-grabbing, You are an overly skilled blogger.
I’ve joined your feed and look ahead to in search of more
of your fantastic post. Also, I have shared your website
in my social networks
LikeLike
March 25, 2016 at 8:42 pm
Awesome! Its really remarkable paragraph, I have got much
clear idea about from this paragraph.
LikeLike
March 29, 2016 at 5:41 pm
Awesome post.
LikeLike
April 4, 2016 at 7:10 pm
Good information. Lucky me I came across your site by chance (stumbleupon).
I have saved as a favorite for later!
LikeLike
September 7, 2017 at 11:18 am
It s very helpful information
If we ve got a disturbance (e.g. flow increasing required) it is recommended to adjust VFD.
Would you please share your idea what criteria should we possibly set such algorithm in DCS to adjust VFD together with CV corresponding to a disturbance for better efficiency and reliability.
LikeLike
August 13, 2018 at 1:28 pm
A very informative blog. Thank you for sharing with us. Visit our website to learn more about VFD and full Automation.
LikeLike
January 4, 2021 at 11:54 pm
Shady, Happy New Year.
We have several 1000 HP and 600 HP Medium Voltage centrifugal blowers on RVSS. The process air header feeds a 5 stage Bardenpho process by means of a FCV, Air Flow Meter, and DO probe for each aeration basin and each basin has a variable DO setpoint. What advantage would I have in upgrading to MV VFD’s vs the existing Inlet Valve Controls on each blower? In addition, we also have a Most-Open-Valve feedback that constantly resets the main header setpoint which then regulates the blower inlet valves.
LikeLike
March 5, 2021 at 1:33 am
VFD are very helpful in metering applications.
LikeLike
May 18, 2021 at 6:38 pm
JAVA Online Training Institute in Noida according to the current business norms. Our preparation projects will empower experts to get placements in multi-national companies. We are giving our elite preparation to every student who needs to get proficient.
LikeLike
August 17, 2021 at 9:49 am
like it ,and keep on
LikeLike